Make an irrevocable decision about a recurring temptation
Remove the choice entirely in the moment of highest temptation by deciding now, permanently.
Why it works
A Ulysses contract (named for Odysseus lashing himself to the mast) removes decision-making authority from your future self at the moment of temptation. Unlike a commitment that can be renegotiated, a Ulysses contract works by making the option physically unavailable or mechanically enforced — so willpower is never required.
How to do it
- Identify the specific temptation you reliably fail at when it’s available.
- Remove the option structurally: delete the app, unsubscribe, give the thing to someone else, block the site at the router level.
- Do not rely on a reminder or notification — the point is that the option no longer exists at the moment of temptation.
Evidence
Structural removal of temptation options (rather than relying on self-control) is supported by ego depletion research showing that willpower is unreliable under stress and fatigue, and by studies showing that people who rely on less self-control by avoiding temptation outperform those who rely on resisting it. (observational)
Ego depletion as a mechanism is contested — a large preregistered replication failed to find the effect. The practical advice (remove the option rather than resist it) is well-supported by research on avoiding versus resisting temptation, even if the depletion mechanism is not the cause.
Sources
- Hagger et al. (2016), "A multilab preregistered replication of the ego-depletion effect", Perspectives on Psychological Science (NB: failed to replicate ego depletion — supports removing temptation rather than willpower-based resistance)
Common mistake
Creating a Ulysses contract that can be undone in under two minutes — the friction of reversal must be high enough that you’d never do it in the moment of temptation.
Practice this with IX Coach
7 days free, then $40/month (~$1.30/day).
More practices for Commitment Contracts, Made Practical
- Write a formal commitment contract with a referee and stakes
Formalize your goal with a clear metric, a deadline, stakes you’ll lose if you fail, and a referee who enforces it.
- Use an anti-charity donation as your stake
Agree to donate to an organization you oppose if you fail — loss framing at its most visceral.
- Choose between carrots and sticks based on your goal type
Sticks (loss-framed penalties) work better for stopping behaviors; carrots (rewards) work better for starting new ones.
- Schedule commitment renewal to prevent drift
Recommit explicitly every few weeks — the motivation that drove the original contract fades faster than the contract itself.
- Make a public commitment to create social accountability
Telling others what you plan to do makes failure visible and costly — a social stake.
- Pre-identify your temptations before writing the contract
Knowing specifically when and how you’ll be tempted lets you write a contract that covers those scenarios.
Related concepts
- Nudge Theory, Made Practical
How the design of choices shapes behavior — and how to exploit that for yourself
- Choice Architecture, Made Practical
Designing your environment so good decisions are the easy ones
- WOOP: Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan
The four steps, the science of mental contrasting, and why fantasy alone fails